When you don't honestly believe something to be the case, but wouldn't be surprised if it turned out to be true.
My friend was so crazy, I half expected him to actually jump off the water tower into a tub of jello when the radio station offered him $10.
by David Fier May 9, 2007
To anticipate the occurrence of an unlikely event while feigning surprise by its ultimate lack of fruition.
by Glitch82 January 19, 2010